MPLS Skyline

Frostbike Preview:  When Frame Candy Takes Too Long

One of the hardest aspects of being a Rockstar Bike Design Engineer, aside from the non-stop parties and the hoards of superfans recognizing me everywhere I go, is showing off new product.  By the time we drop new stuff on the public, like at Frostbike in a few weeks, I've been looking at it for a really, really long time.  

Sometimes, a project goes on for way too long.  This can happen because of performance issues, or tooling issues.  Sometimes, though, it takes too long because the All-City team, a passionate and opinionated group of people, agonizes over how pretty it is.  And sometimes, this agony is over a part of a frame that most people will never think twice about.

Enter:  The All-City Seat Collar

It was a blustery day in July, 2011, when we embarked on The Seat Collar Project.  We were so young... Jeff didn’t even qualify for Masters Category Cyclocross yet.

I was fresh off of designing the Space Horse dropout as a stand-alone piece.


… we didn’t really understand that we would want it to kick off a family of All-City frame parts when I was working on it.  Suddenly, I had a vertical dropout system and a seat collar on the docket. 

The dropout was a piece of cake.  We narrowed in on what we wanted pretty quickly… the one you see on the Mr. Pink and Macho Man Canti. 

(Though, it came pretty close to looking like this:)

07272011 Render 01

07272011 Render 03

The seat collar quickly became a pain in the ass.  Originally, we just wanted pretty frame candy that we could braze on all our models.   

Final Concept SC

But then we shifted direction because we thought it could be cool to have something that we could sell aftermarket (that people could just stick on their collar-less frames).  We split the back of the dropout and started moving in a new direction.

And, for some reason, the concepts kept coming out looking like championship belts:

V3 02

V4 01

Or Viking Helmets:

V6 02

V6 03

We arrived at this theme:


So we went to tooling.  We decided that we would debut it on this sweet model I was working on at the time, The Macho King Canti (see:  

When that model stalled in testing (a crying shame... I love that thing) we had a moment to reflect on the collar design.  It didn't feel right... it was too big on the frame.


I redesigned the little guy.  Shrunk him down, balanced him out, made him lighter.


We ended up with this cutie:





Look for him at Frostbike where he'll be debuting on several models.  



January 30, 2014




January 30, 2014

It’s the details that sold me my natureboy. Can’t wait to see the newest revisions.



January 30, 2014

Speaking of projects on the back burner, has there been any thoughts on moving forward with an 853 MM Disc?



January 31, 2014

I totally agree with Kurt.  The details are why I just bought my second Nature Boy after riding the first one into the ground.


Another Josh

February 14, 2014

+1 on the Macho King Disc comment. I would snap that thing up in a heartbeat.

Leave a comment

Remember my personal information
Notify me of follow-up comments?
* Get your picture next to your comment with a Gravatar Account.

Recent Posts

All Respect to the Craftspeople: Handmade in Taiwan

Where are your bikes made? It's a question that we get often. The answer: Taiwan. We're stoked that many riders and shops are realizing that it's not necessarily where your product is made, it's who's making it. It is in that spirit that we present you with an excerpt from the All-City Annual No 7, an article by our own Nick Paglia about his experiences meeting with and visiting our suppliers.
Read More

2016 NACCC photos by Kevin Sparrow

If you didn't hear the big news, our own Christina Peck once more took home the overall prize at the largest North American Cycle Courier Championships in years. New York threw it down with over 400 riders signing up to take on a closed streets course in Brooklyn.
Read More

Jingle Cross Was Way Cool!

Hey there sports fans, this weekend's gonna be another cyclocross extravaganza and to get you totally psyched beyond possbile imaginable belief we'd like to share a few photos from our trip down to Jingle Cross late last month for several days of racing and the World Cup!
Read More